Published on: January 7, 2025, 02:50h.
Last updated on: January 7, 2025, 02:53h.
The proposal by Wynn Resorts and Related Cos. to establish a casino hotel on the Upper West Side of Manhattan faced a setback as Manhattan Community Board 4 (MCB4) unanimously voted against the necessary zoning changes for the project.
The vote is largely symbolic as MCB4 does not have official authority in the process of selecting downstate casinos, but it emphasizes the importance of local input, particularly from residents of the High Line area. The board expressed concerns about Related’s plan to reduce the number of residential housing units in the development.
Today’s ‘no’ vote offers an opportunity to embrace public-oriented development that creates jobs, builds housing, and preserves the High Line,” said Alan Van Capelle, executive director of Friends of the High Line. “I urge Related to withdraw its application and collaborate with the community to rethink the site for the greater good.”
The final decision on the allocation of three downstate casino licenses lies with the New York State Gaming Commission (NYSGC), with announcements expected later in 2025.
Community Board Vote Indicates Concerns
MCB4’s vote against the zoning changes is not surprising, given their previous objections to Related’s plan to deviate from an agreement that would have provided more housing units.
Related’s $12 billion plan for Western Yards includes office space and the casino proposal, contrary to a 2009 agreement for more residential units. The updated plan features three towers, with two being commercial and one consisting of over 1,500 residential units. One tower will be named after Wynn and span three million square feet.
Last year, Related presented a revised plan to MCB4 that aligned with the 2009 agreement, incorporating affordable housing, a school, and open spaces, which are essential aspects of the casino proposal.
Members of Friends of the High Line opposed the tower plan, citing concerns about obstructing views of the park.
Local Opposition to NYC Casino Projects
Among the 11 contenders for the New York City-area casino licenses, including the Related/Wynn partnership, many are facing resistance from local communities, expressing NIMBY (Not In My Backyard) sentiments. While some do not object to the presence of casinos in the city, they oppose having them in their neighborhoods.
Friends of the High Line has not endorsed the idea of casinos in New York but has made it clear they do not support Related and Wynn’s casino project on the Upper West Side.
“We appreciate Community Board 4 for rejecting Related’s rezoning application without conditions,” added Van Capelle. “You have heard the voices of the community and our supporters, who are advocating to protect the High Line.”